Elmer Eli Benton¹ [P13671] = Mary Ann Thomas² [P13694]

Married BEF 1834
Elmer Eli:

Born 1815, , , , MD USA
Reference number: 15592
He and his wife were having chuldren by 1834 according to information from S. Hollis@@worldnet.att.net. However his age is listed at age 38 in an 1860 census, making his birthyear only 12 or 13 years previous to 1834. In the 1830 census for Belmont Co., OH he is likely the son who was age 10-15 years of age. I highly suspect that he was not having children by 1834.

Mary Ann:

Born 1820
Died 1897
PLAC: 77 years old
Reference number: 15615

Jeannie [P13709] = Frank Robinaugh [P13710] > Family [F4996]

Jeannie:

Reference number: 15630

Frank:

Died BEF 1933
Reference number: 15631

Matilda [P13715] = Levi Robinaugh [P13723] > Family [F2]

Matilda:

Reference number: 15636

Levi:

Died BEF 1933
Reference number: 15644

James M. [P13716]

Born 1834
Reference number: 15637

Eli Alvia [P13717]

Born 1837
Reference number: 15638

Sarah [P13718]

Born 1843
Reference number: 15639

Edward Thomas [P13719] = Mary Alexander [P13727] > Family [F4710]

Edward Thomas:

Born 1843
Died 1918
Reference number: 15640

Mary:

Reference number: 15648

Ruth Ann [P13720] = Daniel Spade [P13728] > Family [F4711]

Ruth Ann:

Born 1845
Reference number: 15641

Daniel:

Reference number: 15649

William Hiram [P13721] = Emily Tyler [P13730] > Family [F4712]

William Hiram:

Born 1852
Reference number: 15642

Emily:

Reference number: 15651

Alvin³ [P8902] = Catherine Trovis Mabrey⁴ [P5995] > Family [F3317]

Married Friday 14 April 1876
Alvin:

Born Saturday 22 May 1852, , Hardin CO, OH USA⁵
Died Sunday 28 April 1912
Buried Harper Cemetery
PLAC: 61 yrs, 11 mos 6 das
Reference number: 10733
Benton homeplace was around LaRue, but since LaRue is close to the Marion County line, not sure whether it was in Hardin or Marion County.
1880 Census Dwelling #3, Family #3 Mt. Victory, Hale Twp, Hardin Co, OH page 8D E.D. 99 Call #/URL T9_1030, Enumeration Date: 2 June Witness Warton Park
Benton, Alvin W Male, age 28, Head of household, Occupation Laborer Birthplace OH, Father's
Birthplace VA Mother's Birthplace VA
Kate W Female age 22, wife Occupation Keeping House, Birthplace PA, Father's
Birthplace PA cannot read or write.
Silvia W Female age 2 mos Birthplace OH, Father's Birthplace OH, Mother's Birthplace PA
1900 Census Dwelling 22, Family #25 Bellefontaine, McArthur Twp, Logan Co, OH, Call Number/URL T623_1294, Sheet No. 1B, Enumeration Date 2/4 June Witness: Guy S. Brooks BENTON
Alvin W Male, Head of Household, occupation farmer, Birth date May 1852, age 48, number of years of marriage 22, place of birth, OH, Father's place of birth MD, Mother's place of birth MD. Can read, write, speak English, Rent farm
Kate W Female, Wife, occupation keeping house, Birth date Mar 1858, age 42, number of children 10, number of children living 7, place of birth PA, Father's birthplace PA, Mother's birthplace PA. Can read, write, speak English
Ira A. W male, son, occupation day laborer, Birth date Feb 1882, age 18, place of birth OH, Father's place of birth OH, Mother's place of birth PA. Can read, write, speak English.
Bennie W male, son, at school, Birth date Aug 1887, age 12, place of birth OH, Father's place of birth
OH, Mother's place of birth PA. Number of month in school 4. Can read, write and speak
English.
Iva E. W daughter, at school, Birth date Aug 1890, age 9, place of birth OH, Father's place of birth OH,
Mother's place of birth PA. Number of months in school 8. Can read, write and speak
English.
Lloyd E. W son, Birth date Aug 1899, age 9 mos, place of birth OH, Father's place of birth OH, Mother's
place of birth PA.
Obituary Bellefontaine Examiner dated April 30, 1912
Alvin Benton was born in Hardin County, May 22, 1851, died April 28, 1912. Age 61 years, 11 months and 6 days. He was married to Miss Kate Maybery April 4, 1876 and to this union was born eleven children, one son and three daughters dying in infancy. He leaves a wife, four daughters and three sons, Mrs. Verna Wallace, Mrs. Wm. Hughes, Mrs. Wm. Pash and Ben Benton, all of Northwood, Mrs. Porter Mummey, of near Kenton, Ora Benton, of Rushsylvania and Lloyd Benton still at home. He also leaves two sisters and one brothers, Mrs. Levi Robinaugh and Mrs. Frank Robinaugh of Bellefontaine and Edward Benton, of DeGraff, together with many relatives and friends to mourn.
Poosibly does not have marker on his grave.

Catherine Trovis:

Born Thursday 26 March 1857, Homessburg, PA USA
Died Wednesday 16 August 1933, At home of son, 801 West Sandusky, Bellefontaine, Logan CO,⁶
Buried Hale Cemetery near Mt. Victory
PLAC: 76 yrs 4 mos 22 das
PLAC: Thursday
Reference number: 7806
Father and mother born in PA
Obituary
Miss Kate Travis Mabrey was born March 26, 1857, daughter of Charley Travis and Sarah Ann Craven Mabrey at Homesburg, PA. She departed this life Thursday, August 17, 1938, at the home of her son, Benjamin F. Benton, 801 West Sandusky Avenue, Bellefontaine.
She was united in marriage in young womanhood to Alvin Benton on April 4, 1877. To this union were born 11 children, five of whom preceded her in death. All died in infancy except one daughter, Mrs. Sylva Wallace, who passed away August 3, 1932.
Mr. Benton also preceded her in death on April 28, 1912.
The children remaining are Ora Benton, of Piqua; Benjamin F., Floyd E. Benton, Mrs. Myrtle Hughes, Mrs. Leona Pash, all of Bellefontaine; Mrs. Iva Mummy, of near Kenton, Mrs. Benton also left two sisters and four brothers, Mrs. Dora McKinney of Covington, Ky.; Mrs. Elizabeth Gilbert, of Akron; John, Lewis and Albert Mabrey, of Kenton, and Homes of Ada. There are 34 grandchildren and 18 great-grandchildren living. Six grandchildren and three great-grandchildren, two sisters, three brothers, Mrs. Ann Burrey, Mrs. Rachel Bales, William, Charley and James Mabrey, her father and mother also one daughter-in-law preceded her in death. She also left two sister-in-law, Mrs. Matilda Robinaugh and Mrs. Jennie Robinaugh of Plumvalley Street, this city and a host of other relative and friends.
After the death of her son's wife she made her home with him till her death.
Date of death recoved in the County death records, book 45 under the date of Aug 17, 1933.

1 : "same sources as Edward Willett"
2 : "Hollis, Susianne S. Hollis to L. Dudick email letters dated"
3 : "Family Info"
Family Info. 1880 census, 1900 census, obituary
4 : "Family Info"
Family Info.1880 census, Mount Victory, Hardin, Ohio, FHL Film #1255030, NA Film # T9-1030, Page #87D. Name isted as Kate Age 22 (1858), Birthplace PA, Occupation Housekeeping, Father's Birthplace PA, Mother's Birthplace PA
4a: "Death Source"
Death Source. Death Certificate
4b: "Family Info"
Family Info. obituary
5 : "Family Info"
Family Info. 1880 Census, Mount Victory, Hardin, Ohio, FHL Film #1255030,
NA Film # T9-1030, Page #87D. Age 28 (1852), Birthplace OH, Occupation Laborer, Father's birthplace VA, Mother's Birthplace VA
6 : "Family Info"
Family Info. 1880 census, Mt. Victory, Hale Twp, Hardin Co, OH pg 8, ED 99, Call #URL T9_1030, enumeration date 2 June